Magic Sam
Given that Sam was a teen male stripper, we did not see nearly enough of what happened during his time on the pole. You’re telling us he didn’t once get down with Channing Tatum or Matthew McConaughey? We all know it’s the real reason Mercedes took him back.

Read more: Glee: The Deleted Scenes We Want to See Next

Not sure what Puck is doing here, but we do know Rory is probably jealous.

And check out: Glee 3-10 “Yes/No” Recaplet

I know it’s all about the actor’s single facial expression (squinty eyes, tender smile) and not the writing, but Rory so looks like he’s dreaming of unwrapping Sam’s package for Christmas.

- LTG, Glee 3-9 “Extraordinary Merry Christmas” Recap

(image via jamiesnewgroove)